Sunday, June 13, 2010

we always treat wemen too well.

“We Always Treat Women Too Well,” by Raymond Queneau was both humorous, yet very witty. In the beginning, Queneau seems to portray the seven Irish rioters as the main characters of the novel; however, by the end of the story, you realize that the “sweet, innocent” character Gertie Gertrude is the actual hero of this fiction. Gertie Gertrude who was first seen hiding out in the bathroom scared to death, seemed so helpless and uneasy. But as the story goes on, she transformed to this confident, intelligent girl, who made a fool out of the seven men who have come to England to gain freedom for their country. Right before the end of the novel, the two remaining Irish men ask of her not to reveal the “dirty deeds” of their comrades. Although at first she seems to have some sort of sympathy for these men, you realize that the entire time she’s just been playing games with them. Once the English bombard the post office and her fiancée asks if these men had done her bad, without a second to think, she simply answers yes. And with that one word answer, the seven men, who originally came to England to become heroes of their country, become pathetic losers without any dignity. Queneau’s portrayal of women seems to be very positive. Through Gertie’s character, you see that Queneau views women as very conniving, yet very clever and powerful. The way he creates this story where a woman outsmarts seven men was very entertaining and original. (sorry its late)

5 comments:

  1. Another "The Things They Carried" reference. Gertie is a more feminine version of the Sweetheart of the Song Tra Bong. She manipulates the masculinity of the Irishmen with her femininity, in order to survive. Her femininity being her weapon of choice.

    Being written from by a man, under a female pseudonym, could suggest that he feels femininity has a power over men that they may not even realize.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think that this idea of woman using their sexuality as a weapon has some bearing in the real world. Women are commonly used to distract men during robberies or persuade them to give up valuable information. However, for all the power women have over men, I think they have more of a positive influence overall. As the saying goes "behind every great man is a great woman."

    ReplyDelete
  4. Well, I agree with Alexander. How long have men known women have an influence over men? A fun book is 'Reveries of a Bachelor' where a man goes through all of his grievances pertaining to a woman, but it was written a while ago, don't ask me for the year :-P Many men wrote under female pseudonyms. The reason was that a sentimental story, i.e 'feeling' story, 'girlie' story, or something sounding like this novel would have sold better if written by a woman. men are quite emotional and can write some pretty sentimental stuff. We just don't really encourage it as much from a man :-)

    ReplyDelete
  5. ^^I think a lot of the time when men try to convey their emotions it comes out kind of sappy, which is why it is more rare for us men to write emotional works than for women. Or maybe us men just think it comes out sappy and that's why we shy away from it. The one exception is, of course, music. There are SO many emotional songs written by men and it is completely encouraged by society. I'm not saying that is inherently bad, but I think there is definitely a lot of emotional music is mass produced and sappy, and takes attention and money away from artists with sincere artistic talent.

    ReplyDelete