Tuesday, June 7, 2011

The Instant of My Death/Demure

One thing that stuck out to me in Blanchot's story and Derrida's analysis was the nature of fiction as a whole because when one thinks about fiction, the basic implication is that it’s something made up, a story about characters that never existed. Writing fictional novels or stories gives the author the ability to be more flexible because, simply put, if he or she wants to add or subtract something it’s easy to do since the story isn’t real. However, fiction doesn’t necessarily mean fake. Sure, there are plenty of things that are “based on a true story,” but what about when a work of fiction isn’t just based on a true story, but is a totally true story by itself, is it really still fiction? The Instant of My Death seems to be a work of pure fiction about a young boy that manages to escape death during WWII. Although there wasn’t really any boy and nothing in the story actually happened Derrida mentions in Demeure that Blanchot, his friend, once told him about a real life situation that inspired the story. If a story is written as a way to represent real events, then, in a way, it blends the line between fiction and non-fiction. This is a fairly common occurrence showing that just because something may fall under the category of fiction, doesn’t necessarily mean that it isn’t true.

3 comments:

  1. I really like how you related fiction to reality. I absolutly agree with this idea. There is so much fact and reality behind most fiction, which is contrary to what one would normally think, and this is very well illustrated by Demeure. To answer your question, I do think that a story can still be fiction even though it is based on real events. In my post, I made a comment about how all fiction has some experience behind it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree that most fictional stories have a lot of underlying truth. I think that the best fiction novels are the stories that you can really relate. The truth behind the experience is what makes the story come to life. I also think you bring up a great point when you argue, fictional stories give authors more flexibility and freedom to create a story filled with more dramatic language. When the author creates a more dramatic experience then the english language comes to life and makes the story much more exciting to read.

    ReplyDelete
  3. You make a good point that when a story is fiction, but written to represent real events then it definitely shows the relationship between fiction and non-fiction.

    ReplyDelete